California Court Clarifies Rules on Prolonged and Pretextual Traffic Stops
Court reinforces that the duration of a traffic stop is measured from the time of the stop until a driver is released or new reasonable suspicion is developed. The decision clarifies that pretextual stops are permitted under California Vehicle Code…
To Search or Not to Search: Case Explores When it’s Lawful to Search an Impounded Car and When it’s Not
An inventory search of a legally impounded vehicle must be limited to establishing an inventory of its contents – but a warrantless inventory search of a vehicle done specifically to look for evidence of criminal wrongdoing violates the Fourth…
Ninth Circuit Limits High-Risk Vehicle Stops: New Potential Liability Risks for Police
The Ninth Circuit’s decision in a Los Angeles auto-theft case restricts the use of high-risk vehicle stops based solely on an officer's belief that the vehicle is stolen, ruling that officers must have specific reasons to believe the occupants…
Ninth Circuit Rules Deadly Force Justified in the Fatal Shooting of a Knife-Wielding, Mentally Ill Man
The court ruled that deadly force was reasonable given the circumstances, emphasizing the severity of the crime, whether the threat was immediate and the man’s resistance. His mental illness wasn’t relevant, the court said, and it ruled the officers…
Ninth Circuit Rules Parole Questions During Traffic Stops Are Constitutionally Valid
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that asking about a driver’s parole status during a traffic stop is a constitutionally valid safety measure. This decision affirms that such questions, directly related to officer safety, do not…